574. IF AND WHETHER

WHETHER AND IF

 

1. INDIRECT QUESTIONS

WHETHER and IF can both introduce indirect questions:

a. He asked IF/WHETHER I knew Paul;

b. The police officer asked IF/WHETHER I had seen the accident.



In a formal style, WHETHER is usually preferred in a two-part question with OR to emphasize a choice:

a. The travel agent asked WHETHER I wanted to go by air OR by sea.

b. The waiter asked WHETHER I wanted chicken OR fish and chip.

Note the use of WHETHER or NOT to emphasize a choice:

a. He asked WHETHER or NOT I wanted to insure my luggage.

 2.PREPOSITIONS

After prepositions, only WHETHER is possible:

a. There was a big argument ABOUT WHETHER we should move to a new house (NOT… about IF we should move);

b. I haven’t settled the question OF WHETHER I’ll go back home.

 3.INFINITIVES

WHETHER, but not IF, is used before to-infinitives:

a. They can’t decide WHETHER TO GET married now or wait (NOT they can’t decide if to get married);

b. He wondered WHETHER TO WAIT for them or go on;

c. He couldn’t remember WHETHER TO TURN right or left.

4. SUBJECT, COMPLEMENT AND ADVERBIAL CLAUSES

When a question-word clause is a subject or a complement, WHETHER is normally used:

a. WHETHER WE CAN STAY with my mother is another matter (SUBJECT);

b. The question is WHETHER THE MAN CAN BE TRUSTED (COMPLEMENT).

 

THE QUESTION IS IF …is also possible, but less common:

The question is IF THE MAN CAN BE TRUSTED.

 

 

Pubblicato da funnyenglish

An English blog for English lovers!